Since 1991, America’s #1 Rack Specialty StoreAmerica's #1 Rack Store
Expert Phone SupportPrice Guarantee
Ski Racks vs. Rooftop Cargo Box
When it comes to optimizing your vehicle's storage capacity for outdoor adventures, rooftop accessories become invaluable assets. Amidst a wide array of choices, Ski Racks and Cargo Boxes emerge as highly coveted options, each tailored to specific needs and individual preferences. However, both share the common capability of transporting skis, snowboards, and winter gear, prompting the question of which one is the superior choice. In the forthcoming pages of this blog, we embark on a journey of exploration, meticulously dissecting the subtleties and advantages inherent in these two essential additions.
Our aim is to empower you with the knowledge required to make an informed decision that will enhance your upcoming outdoor excursions. Whether you're a passionate skier in search of a dependable Ski Rack or a seasoned traveler in need of the versatile Cargo Box, this comprehensive examination will function as your compass, guiding you in the selection of the ideal rooftop accessory to elevate your outdoor experiences. Join us as we delve into the intricacies of these indispensable tools, providing you with the insight and clarity necessary to ensure that your vehicle is suitably equipped to meet the rigors of your next adventure.
Purpose and Utility
Ski Rack - Hauling Winter Sports Gear
Rooftop ski racks are designed primarily for transporting winter sports equipment, including skis, snowboards, and potentially poles if your ski carrier has adequate space. They offer a specialized solution for a specific purpose.
Cargo Boxes - Versatile Storage Solutions
On the other hand, rooftop cargo boxes are multipurpose carriers that can accommodate a wide range of items, from skis and snowboards, sports equipment, luggage, and camping gear. They offer more versatility for various travel needs making their overall useability much higher.
Capacity and Size
Ski Rack - Limited Space
Ski racks typically have limited space, and their capacity is based on the number of pairs of skis or snowboards they can hold. They generally range from 2 pairs to 6 pairs of skis. Or in the case of snowboards 2 to 4 boards. You can of course mix equipment in the carrier if you have the space.
Cargo Boxes - Spacious Storage
Rooftop cargo boxes are available in a range of sizes, providing a notably greater storage capacity in comparison to ski racks. They are versatile enough to transport a wide array of items beyond just skis and snowboards, making them well-suited for extended journeys and family vacations.
Installation and Assembly
Ski Rack - Quick and Easy every time
Mounting ski racks is typically an uncomplicated task, requiring you to secure them onto your vehicle's roof crossbars. These ski racks often come with universal mounting hardware, enabling them to be easily attached to various crossbar styles. Furthermore, most ski racks are designed to be tool-free, allowing for quick attachment and removal in just a matter of minutes.
Cargo Boxes - More Involved Initial Setup
Installing cargo boxes is generally a straightforward task, but their larger size and weight may necessitate the assistance of another person to lift them onto your vehicle's roof. Cargo boxes are also equipped with universal mounting hardware, making it easy to attach them to various styles of crossbars. Most cargo boxes feature a tool-free design that allows for quick tightening and loosening, typically taking only a few minutes to complete.
Ski Rack - Easy Access to Gear
Ski racks offer the advantage of convenience when it comes to accessibility. When your skis or snowboards are securely mounted on the roof, accessing them becomes effortless, especially if you have a ski rack model that extends outward beyond the side of your vehicle.
Cargo Boxes - Limited Accessibility
Though cargo boxes offer generous storage space and accessing your belongings is still quite manageable. Tt does involve opening the cargo box and climbing up to retrieve your skis. It's important to note that skis and snowboards inside the cargo box may be loosely positioned, potentially leading to shifting if they're not properly secured with straps.
Ski Rack - Minimal Weather Protection
Ski racks provide minimal to no weather protection. Your skis and snowboards will be exposed to the elements, including rain, snow, salt, and harsh winter weather conditions.
Cargo Boxes - Excellent Weatherproofing
Rooftop cargo boxes are significantly better designed to shield your belongings from the elements, particularly during the winter season. While cargo boxes may not be entirely waterproof, they come remarkably close to it, especially in the case of higher-end models. This makes cargo boxes an excellent option for safeguarding and transporting your gear and possessions during extended trips, even when encountering challenging weather conditions.
Aerodynamics and Fuel Efficiency
Ski Rack - Minimal Impact
Ski racks typically have a minimal impact on your vehicle's aerodynamics and fuel efficiency, thanks to their sleek and streamlined design. They are unlikely to cause a significant decrease in your gas mileage.
Cargo Boxes - Potential for Reduced Efficiency
Cargo boxes, due to their larger size, may exert a more noticeable influence on your vehicle's aerodynamics. This can lead to a modest decrease in fuel efficiency and increased drag on the vehicle, particularly when driving at higher speeds. Some lower profile models such as the Inno Wedge 11 or Thule Motion XT Alpine help with this thanks to their low, sleek profile. However, at the end of the day they are still a cargo box on top of your vehicle and are bound to create more drag than a more minimal ski carrier
Ski Rack - Limited Security
Ski racks offer basic security through keyed locks that prevent theft of your equipment. However, they may not be as secure as cargo boxes in deterring theft or preventing tampering. Higher end models such as the Yakima FatCat EVO or Thule SnowPack do a better job keeping things secure with locking capability for the mounting hardware, although your gear will always be visible with this style of carrier.
Cargo Boxes - Enhanced Security
Rooftop cargo boxes typically come equipped with stronger locking mechanisms, providing enhanced security for your belongings. Additionally, the concealed nature of cargo boxes adds an extra layer of security by keeping the contents hidden from view. These factors make cargo boxes the preferred choice for safeguarding valuable items.
Ski Rack - Budget-Friendly
The ski rack option is generally more budget-friendly than cargo boxes, making them an economical choice for those on a tight budget or those who only need occasional ski transport. If you do want to splash some cash on a fancy ski carrier, even the highest end carriers like the Thule SnowPack Extender wont run you the price of an entry-level basic cargo box.
Cargo Boxes - Higher Investment
Rooftop cargo boxes tend to be pricier due to their larger size, more cargo space and added features. However, their versatility can justify the higher upfront cost for frequent travelers.
Ski Rack - Streamlined Look
The ski rack design offers a streamlined and minimalistic appearance on your vehicle, preserving its original design aesthetics without adding much visual bulk.
Cargo Boxes - Bulkier Appearance
Cargo boxes, due to their larger and more conspicuous nature, can change the appearance of your vehicle and may not be aesthetically pleasing to all users. However, depending on the specific cargo box model, they have the potential to enhance the appeal of your vehicle. Models such as the Thule Vector Alpine are very popular with car enthusiast looking for a stylish cargo
Durability and Longevity
Ski Rack - Simple Construction
Ski racks are typically designed with a straightforward and robust build, which adds to their longevity. With appropriate care, they can endure many seasons of use.
Cargo Boxes - Robust Build
Rooftop cargo boxes are usually crafted from tough materials capable of enduring years of use and exposure to various weather conditions. Their robustness validates the initial purchase, and many cargo boxes come with outstanding warranty coverage.
Ski Rack - Universal Fit
Ski racks are designed to fit most vehicles with crossbars, making them a versatile option for different cars, SUVs, and trucks.
Cargo Boxes - Size-Specific Compatibility
Rooftop cargo boxes come in various sizes and shapes, and it's crucial to ensure compatibility with your specific vehicle model to avoid any fitment issues.
Ski Rack - Minimal Noise
Ski racks may create slight wind noise when driving at moderate speeds, with the level of noise fluctuating based on the type of vehicle.
Cargo Boxes - Potential Wind Noise
Cargo boxes, particularly larger ones, can produce a degree of wind noise, especially noticeable at higher speeds. The level of noise can also vary based on the vehicle to which it is mounted. Certain models are equipped with noise-reduction features designed to mitigate this wind noise.
Ski Rack - Compact Storage
When not in use, ski racks can be easily removed and stored in your garage or basement, taking up minimal space.
Cargo Boxes - Bulkier Storage
Storing cargo boxes can pose a challenge due to their size, often requiring a dedicated space in your garage or shed when they are not in use. One convenient option for cargo box storage is utilizing hanging storage solutions offered by companies like Thule and Malone.
Ski Rack - Lighter Load
Ski racks usually feature lower weight limits in comparison to cargo boxes. They are designed to accommodate ski equipment but are not well-suited for transporting other items.
Cargo Boxes - Heavier Loads
Rooftop cargo boxes are designed to handle heavier loads, making them ideal for transporting various items such as skis, snowboards, luggage, camping gear, and more.
Ease of Use
Ski Rack - User-Friendly
Ski racks are known for their user-friendly design, allowing for easy loading and unloading of skis and snowboards. Ski racks designed to extend beyond the side of the vehicle further enhance the convenience of this process.
Cargo Boxes - More Involved
Cargo boxes may require more effort to load and secure items, especially if you have larger or heavier cargo. They can be less user-friendly in this regard.
User Experience and Preferences
Ski Rack - Simplistic Appeal
Many users value the straightforwardness and convenience of ski racks, coupled with their budget-friendly price point, which makes ski racks a valuable choice for many winter sports enthusiasts.
Cargo Boxes - Versatile Appeal
Rooftop cargo boxes are designed to accommodate a wider spectrum of users who prioritize versatility, the capacity to transport a variety of items while safeguarding them from weather and theft. Furthermore, they prove exceptionally efficient for diverse activities and trips, not limited to just transporting skis and snowboards.
In summary, the decision between rooftop ski racks and rooftop cargo boxes hinges on your individual requirements and preferences. If you mainly participate in winter sports and prioritize affordability and convenience in storage, ski racks are a great option. Conversely, if you desire versatility, weather protection, and improved security for a variety of cargo, rooftop cargo boxes are the preferable choice. Deliberate on the factors outlined in this comparison to make an informed decision that enriches your outdoor experiences.